top of page

Is your business being held captive by the increasing cost of health insurance?

Keep more of your hard-earned revenue

with health insurance broker and consulting services from MAGIC

Offer awesome benefits to your incredible employees

Grow Your Business

Improve Your Bottom Line

Do your insurance benefits make you feel like you’re stuck between a rock and a hard place?

defeated business man with head down on laptop

We see it all the time: Well-meaning business owners and management teams want to attract and retain top-notch employees, so you commit to offering the best health insurance options possible. You find a health insurance broker, pick a plan, and then . . . 

  • Realize the annually increasing costs of offering health insurance is hampering the growth of your business.

  • Waste time and energy every year navigating open enrollment and decisions on what to cut and what to keep. 

  • Find your employees don’t like the coverage you provide and look for other jobs

How much are your health insurance problems costing you in time, energy, and wasted money?

You Deserve Better

At MAGIC Health Insurance Solutions, we’re a health insurance broker and consultant here to help you think about your health insurance differently. We’re sick and tired of seeing small businesses be held captive by the increasing costs of health insurance. It is our passion to help you take back control of this out-of-control expense and show innovative ideas and strategies that help you keep your hard-earned revenue, grow your business, and improve your bottom line.

We’ve helped companies save as much as $5 million dollars on their insurance spend without sacrificing quality benefits for employees. What could you do with that kind of budget surplus?

happy business woman dances in joy

The MAGIC Difference

Icon of a dollar sign

We Don’t Work On Commission

We hate to put it bluntly, but the insurance companies could care less about you. You are simply a small stream of revenue to help them meet their shareholders demands and meet Wall Street expectations.

Many traditional brokers don’t fight rate increases because with each one, they get a pay increase, too. Who doesn’t like a 10% bump in pay every year?

At MAGIC, we work on a flat-fee system based on the number of covered employees. Our business only grows when yours does, too!

Icon of a heart

We’re Data Driven
(with heart)

More than anything, we want to do what’s best for you – the client. To figure that out, we dive deep into your data to see what’s happening with your claims and coverage.

Whether you add us as a consulting advisor or as a health insurance broker of record, we’re committed to finding you the BEST solutions to save your hard-earned money and improve your bottom-line without sacrificing quality care for your employees. You might be surprised at how much control you really can have over health insurance costs!

Icon of a lightbulb

We Think
Outside The Box

We get to know your business and your needs, and then recommend multiple alternative insurance options to fit your goals.

Just because your insurance has always been handled a certain way doesn’t mean it’s the best way!


With new possibilities available in health insurance benefits, it’s time to take a second look at what you’re offering your employees. It IS possible to provide high quality benefits while keeping more of your hard-earned revenue!

Our Strategies

These are just a few of the 35 concepts we recommend to keep costs down and free up capital.

business executive woman stares at laptop

Health Reimbursement Arrangement

Have you ever had the feeling you had a good year, no major claims, but still received a renewal increase from your insurance carrier?


A Health Reimbursement Arrangement (HRA) is an IRS-approved, employer-funded medical reimbursement plan linked with a group health insurance plan. This allows employers to self-insure a portion of their group insurance plan using pre-tax dollars which leads to big savings without any change in coverage.

cheerful male worker uses laptop at industrial site

Level Funding

Are you struggling to find healthcare benefits solutions that give you the control, flexibility and value you need?


With level-funding you get better control over your health benefits, the flexibility to tailor your plan design to your specific needs, and the opportunity to realize savings if your group’s claims are lower than expected.

business woman looking at insurance plan documents

Self Funding

What are the advantages of self-funding and why are more companies switching from a one-size-fits-all approach? 

Because of the broad scope of control provided, the most cost-effective approach is to self-fund your health insurance plan. Changing from a one size fits all, fully insured plan to self-funding will help you:

  • Control costs

  • Enhance your cash flow

  • Understand each element of your healthcare spend

man discussing health insurance with receptionist

Medical Management

If you’re not doing everything in your power to aggressively manage your medical and prescription claims costs, your costs will continue to spiral out of control. 

By incorporating proactive medical management practices, your members will be able to engage in a healthier lifestyle, producing better outcomes for them and financial results for your company.

chief financial officer accountant with spreadsheets doing calculations

Reference Based Pricing

If there ever was “smoke and mirrors” in the world of healthcare, how your doctors or hospitals bill for their services would certainly qualify. 

With Reference Based Pricing, you will see exactly what is being charged for a claim, which can provide insight into how your plan is running.

woman discussing prescription drug prices with pharmacist


Prescriptions are the top driver of costs for your health insurance plan, increasing by over 10% a year

Because they comprise at least 25% of your overall expenses, you must proactively manage these costs just like every other aspect of your business.

Not sure how to do that? Give us a call!

Break Free in 3 Easy Steps:

A man watches a video call on his laptop computer

1. Meet With Us

Set up a virtual or face-to-face meeting.

A man looks at a business document

2. Review Our Analysis

We’ll provide an overview of possible solutions for you to review.

A man and a woman are smiling and shaking hands while another woman looks on

3. Take Control

Keep your hard-earned revenue so you can grow your business and improve your bottom line.

You deserve an
insurance partner you can trust.

Bill Geraci owner of Magic Health Insurance
Ilya Geraci of Magic Health Insurance

We are passionate about small business and we want you to succeed! We have seen too many wonderful businesses lose money, talent, or have to close their doors because of badly managed or poorly selected health insurance. This doesn’t have to be you! We have been helping companies of all sizes since 2007, and after 15 years we know that our bottom line takes care of itself when we take care of our clients.

It’s time to treat your health insurance spend like every other aspect of your company. It’s time to have a health insurance broker on your side who knows what the heck they’re doing and will proactively manage your expenses every day. It’s time to hold someone accountable for controlling this cost and show a demonstrable ROI!


We’ve helped companies save as much as $5 million dollars on their insurance spend without sacrificing quality benefits for employees. Isn’t a return like that worth a second look at your benefits package?

Association of Insurance Leadership innovation award logo
Ohio growth association for health insurance logo

"Bill's knowledge and guidance has provided us vital insight in developing and maintaining our portfolio of health insurance benefits."

Logo for Liberty Distributors

Nathan Pelechutte

Liberty Distributors


"Bill' truly understands that our small company is a close-knit group and that we want to provide the very best for them and their families."

R&R Fabrications company logo

Pam Reinhart

R&R Fabrications


Business owners often don’t realize that health insurance and employee benefits can be managed more effectively for cost-savings. And this doesn’t mean slashing employee benefits! 

With the MAGIC team as your health insurance broker, we’ll provide innovative strategies customized to your business needs. We help you take back control of your benefit options so you can keep hard-earned revenue to grow your business and improve your bottom line.

A man and a woman scrutinize a laptop screen

Contact Us!

Thanks for submitting!

We will get back to you shortly!

bottom of page